Personal help please?!?!?

Go with whomever you're more interested in. So if it's really Jeff, let Doug know you made a little boo-boo and got caught in that glamorous moment of his. I think you should call him NOW! and clear things up and let him know that there's another guy you like. He's going to get upset maybe even mad, so prepare yourself for that. You simply made a mistake we all do that.